Police, Courts, Lawyers and Prisons: Who Really Shapes Justice Outcomes? by Hannah Kintum

Amnesty International rightly said that the criminal justice system in Nigeria is a “conveyor belt of injustice from beginning to end” and that all its components contribute towards delivering or denying justice in their own ways. The police, courts, lawyers and prisons all interact within a single system, and the failure of any of them will automatically affect the rest and as a ripple effect, it would also affect the justice that is provided to millions of Nigerians. Who determines the outcome of all this needs to be seen by understanding the functioning of each of the institutions under the laws of Nigeria.

 

The police are the point of contact of the criminal justice system. The functioning of the police ultimately decides whether the individual enters the criminal justice system by himself or through arrest and detention. Section 35(4) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 as amended states that any person arrested or detained by the police or any other law enforcement agency shall be taken before a court within a reasonable time.

 

In instances where a suspect cannot be arraigned before a court during such a period, the Constitution mandates that the suspect should be set free on bail with or without conditions. The above provisions by the Constitution define the limits of police powers on detention but the police often breach these requirements. In the Police Act of 2020, it is stated that the Police Officer in charge of a Police station should set free a suspect on bail when he/she enters into a recognizance with or without sureties. Notwithstanding the above legal provisions, police extortion is common in Nigeria, as many officers extort money from citizens to open case files or grant bail to a suspect. These actions not only threaten the rule of law, they undermine the confidence of the public and may lead to some victims not reporting crimes.

 

Another institution in the justice system is the court. It has a duty to check how the police conduct themselves to make sure that the constitutional rights of citizens are respected and upheld. Unfortunately, delay in the judicial process and backlog have turned courts from being instruments of justice to instruments of injustice. One major obstacle facing the courts is the backlog of cases. There are not enough judges and courtrooms in Nigeria and this leads to an overload of dockets and long periods for hearing simple legal cases. To solve this issue, the Administration of Criminal Justice Act 2015 has made some necessary amendments, for instance, the requirement to make magistrates review remand orders periodically in order to make sure that a suspect does not stay in limbo during his or her time in detention.

 

However, the success of the reform measures is still constrained by the number of cases and lack of enough judicial personnel. The time taken to bring cases to the courts is so long that once the prisoner has been prosecuted and found guilty of the offenses, he does not wish to pursue the matter further. Even those who claim innocence argue that it is better off serving their sentences than remaining in custody during the period of pursuing the case through the appeals processes. In such circumstances, the process of appealing becomes another form of punishment in addition to an extended period in jail.

 

Lawyers also have a significant influence on the administration of justice. They represent parties in a case, ensure respect for the constitution and challenge unlawful detention. However, the availability of lawyers in Nigeria is not sufficient since the majority of prisoners do not have money to pay a lawyer. Also, lawyers in the police stations act as a deterrent to the excesses of the police with respect to torture and cruel treatment.

 

The prisons are the last piece in the chain of criminal justice process. Unfortunately, in Nigeria, they serve as a warehouse of unjust detention rather than places where punishment and reform of convicted criminals takes place. Approximately 65 percent of inmates in Nigerian prisons have not ever been convicted for any crime and some have waited in prison for more than ten years for their trial to take place. The detention facilities in Nigeria have been characterized as difficult, with provisions such as food, health services and others failing to conform to the minimum standards of the UN Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules).

 

Issues of overcrowding, lack of medical and health services, lack of adequate toilet facilities and beddings and denial of justice continue to persist in glaring defiance of the standards of the UN on how persons should be treated in custody. Also, most of these prisons are 70 to 80 years old and lack basic facilities; lack of potable water, poor sewage facilities and overcrowding leading to unhealthy and unsafe sanitary conditions characterize most of the prisons. Individuals not suspected of any criminal acts are often jailed together with the convicted individuals. It is glaring that the Nigerian government has failed to fulfill its duties both nationally and internationally regarding the criminal justice process in Nigeria.

 

It is impossible to declare any one of these justice-involved institutions as dominant because they all play vital and essential roles that contribute to achieving justice or suffering injustice. It is important to understand the way failures at each step result in injustice. At the first step, the police make arbitrary arrests and serve out excessive detention of people beyond the constitutional periods. The courts suffer from severe backlogs, corruption and the lack of judicial personnel. Lawyers are inaccessible for most of the population because of poverty and the lack of practitioners in legal aid. All these in their own ways contribute to the broken down justice system in Nigeria.

 

The process of dispensing justice and more often than not, injustice in Nigeria is determined by the cumulative failure of these institutions that lead to the denial and infringement of the rights of millions of Nigerians enshrined in the Constitution, especially the poor among them. While there have been some legal frameworks for the reform of the Nigerian justice system through the Administration of Criminal Justice Act 2015, there are still problems in the implementation because of lack of adequate funding and corruption.

Scroll to Top